Moody's Investor Services
and Fitch Ratings have both indicated that they are
considering following Standard & Poor's recent decision
to downgrade Fiat's shares to below investment grade
status, concerned by liquidity and a weakening
performance this year.
Dropping Fiat's debt
ratings further below investment grade status into the
infamous "junk" category could have repercussions for
Fiat in terms of banking institutions being prevented
from holding its financial instruments as well as the
carmaker having to pay higher interest charges.
Both Moody's and Fitch
became jittery after Fiat announced that it would raise
its stake in Chrysler Group, promoting concerns about
the Italian carmaker's liquidity. Fitch said on April 21
it had placed Fiat on its "rating watch negative" and
its long term debt, currently rated at BB+ (already a
non investment grade status), under review for possible
downgrade. Gradings below BBB/Baa are more commonly
known as "junk bonds". Fiat's short-term debut was
however unchanged at "B" (also no investment grade).
Moody’s Investors
Service, on the same day, announced that it had also
placed its own rating on Fiat's long term debt,
currently at Ba1 (the equivalent to BB+), under review
for a possible downgrade. A Moody's analyst explained in
a briefing note that Fiat is "vulnerable to a drop-off
in demand" in its two key markets, Italy and Brazil, as
well as highlighting the lack of new models debuting in
Europe. Fiat is the worst performing major carmaker in
Europe this year in year-on-year terms and its market
share has tumbled. The note also emphasised Fiat's
overreliance on certain markets, adding that its "very
limited geographic diversification" is one of its "key
weaknesses." However the note did point out that the
Chrysler Group alliance will help to address this
deficiency.
Standard & Poor's,
which in February set the Fiat downgrade ball rolling by
dropping its rating out of investment grade status to
"BB+" level (the highest category of the non investment
'junk' grade rating), said at the time in a statement:
"We lowered the rating due mainly to our assessment of
its liquidity situation." Standard & Poor's credit
analyst Barbara Castellano, said: "This limits Fiat's
financial flexibility and leaves it more exposed to a
weaker than expected performance in 2011." She added
that there are "very substantial operating and financial
risks related to Fiat's increased exposure to Chrysler."
Standard & Poor's however left the ratings position
unchanged on the recent announcement that Fiat would pay
US1.27 billion for an additional 16 percent cash stake
to take its holding in Chrysler by the summer to 46
percent.